LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 349 Moore in his capacity as agent for said firm and not as an executor of the estate of G. Moore , contracted the debt which Lionel Hart & Co. , appellee in this suit, seeks to recover . Before proceeding further we would observe , that from the business letters that were written to said appellee by H. J. Moore as the agent of said firm , as well as from the entire conduct of said firm towards the appellee , we have discovered no grounds upon which to draw a legal inference of an intent to commit either positive or con- structive fraud . Nor do the said communications dis- close the fact that means of cunning , deception or artifice were employed to induce Lionel Hart & Co. , appellee , to deal with and credit said firm , at any time , or in any wise to mislead said firm. It does appear that at the time the debt was contracted , the said firm of G. Moore & Son , of which H. J. Moore was acting agent , did really exist and was actually conducting mercantile business at Monrovia under the name and style of G. Moore & Son . "Courts of equity, sitting to decide whether or not a transaction be fraudulent , will be governed by the cir- cumstances surrounding the case and the intent of the party, which intent is to be inferred from the circum- stances ; it is generally held to be a part of the equity doctrine of fraud not to define it ; not to lay down any rule as to the nature of it , lest the craft of men should find ways of committing fraud which might escape the rules of such limit or definition . But it is also held that to constitute fraud there must exist artifice , decep- tion , or cheat ." We shall now consider our second proposition . It was impliedly expressed in one of the queries submitted for the consideration of the court below , that the executors of the estate of G. Moore & Son having stood by and allowed the transaction to go on , cannot absolve them- selves from responsibility to third parties , who by their negligence have been misled ; and this position was main-