LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 269 the opinion that the court below , and the jury , should have taken into consideration the rule of mitigation of damages , because of the misconduct or provocation proved by the testimony , as well as the right of men to protect their premises . Carefully looking into all the circumstances surround- ing this case, we are forced to the following conclusions : First , that the verdict rendered in this case is against the law and the evidence ; second , that the judgment ren- dered based upon said verdict is unlawful , not being founded upon a lawful verdict . Therefore , to sustain such proceedings would work great damage , and would place mercantile houses at the mercy of intruders . Therefore this court adjudges that the judgment ren- dered in this case is hereby reversed , and that the appel- lant recover from the appellee his legal costs in this action ; and further , that the clerk of this court issue a lawful mandate to the court in which the action was tried , to the effect of this judgment . CHARLES H. DUNBAR , Appellant , vs. REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1895.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . False Imprisonment . This case was tried in the Court of Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , at its May term , 1894 , and is brought before this court upon a bill of exceptions , for review . The exceptions taken below are as follows : First , "Be- cause the court overruled a motion offered by the defen- dant below , praying an abatement of the indictment and process because of its uncertainty in setting forth the Christian name of the defendant and not describing him with certainty ." Second, "Because the indictment