192 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS corpus, questioned the authority upon which the judg- ment was given , and assumed the power and authority to review the same. In fact little respect is paid by him to the authorities , who lay it down as a settled question that no court has a right to review a matter on habeas corpus. ( Bouv . Law Dict . Vol . I , p . 352 , sec . 6, under the head "Contempt ." ) Hence , I regard the written paper (called opinion ) of the Attorney General a contemptuous paper, first , because it was written for the purpose of stopping the effect of the judgment , and that I should know it, a copy of the same was sent me in court , show- ing the reasons relied upon why the bill of costs should not be paid . This act , when constructively considered , is an open contempt to the court , in its presence , and it is also an outrage upon the judiciary , tending to deprive the people of the benefits which by the Constitution of Liberia ought to be enjoyed in the freest manner on habeas corpus . I am compelled to say from the position taken by the Attorney General , that he has attached greater powers to his office than has been given by the Legislature . One of the many duties of his office ( defined by statute ) is to advise the general government officers on all legal questions touching the duties of their several offices . And it is in respect to a want of a proper understanding of this part of his duty , that the question arises as to what is a" legal question ." It is one when the doubt or differences arise as to what the law is, on a certain state of facts . This is said to be a legal question , and if the party demurs , this is to bedecided bythejudge . ( Bouv . Law Dict . Vol .II , p . 403 , under head " Question ;" also Lib . Stat . Book I, p . 16 , under head " Trial .") It is here described that the trial of all questions of mere law shall be by the court . It must therefore be remembered that the phrase " legal question " is applicable only when it arises on a certain state of facts , and that such a question can only be decided by a court of law having jurisdiction over the