380 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS in this particular case . To the plea of insanity , upon which the case chiefly rested , the testimony of witness. Moore was indeed of great weight and value to the deter- mination of said plea . This court is unanimously of the opinion that the testimony of the aforesaid witnesses did establish a cogent case in favor of the accused , which the State should have rebutted by evidence of such preponderance as would have excluded every reasonable and rational doubt as to the guilt of the accused . (I Arch . Crim . Prac. and Pleadings , p . 350, note 1 ; I Bouv. Law Dict . pp . 717 , 718 , under the head of "Insanity .") As to the second and third queries , the court would remark before proceeding further that homicide is divided by the common law authorities into three classes, namely , excusable homicide , felonious homicide or murder , and justifiable homicide . To constitute murder , which is the crime for which the accused was indicted , there must be a wilful killing of some human being, and there must appear to have been malice , either expressed or such as can legally be implied . According to Coke's definition. of the term (II Bouv . Law Dict . p . 201 , under the head of "Murder ") , the agent must be of sound mind. and memory ; and this definition of Mr. Coke is sustained by most , if not all , of the English and American common law writers . Insanity , therefore , is a good and lawful plea in cases for murder , and if clearly and substantially proven will operate as a bar to a prosecution for murder , by show- ing that the law regards such homicide as excusable . But great care should be exercised in acquitting a prisoner on this plea . It would be as difficult as it would be unsafe , to lay down a rule that would apply to the infinite variety of forms in which insanity or derange- ment may show itself . Each case must therefore depend very much upon the circumstances , facts and develop- ments which attend it.