LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 325 judge below should be sustained in said ruling or not . From reviewing the record in the case , the court finds that the motion of appellant referred to contains a prayer to the court below for the restoration of the goods which appellant is charged with smuggling , for four reasons , viz : "First , that he considers that the instrument of writing of libellant does not purport to be a libel filed against said goods , which would constitute an action in rem . Second, that it does not purport to be an action in personam . Third , that the seizure of said goods was made by persons not authorized by law so to do. Fourth , that the libellee never refused to pay the legal duties on said goods . ' "" Now, then, this court says that it is puzzled to under- stand the motive that influenced libellee , now appellant , to join issue with libellant , now appellee , by answering the libel and joining the reply , the issue being complete and finished , and last of all, to put in a motion praying for summary relief ; for in the opinion of the court the new allegations laid in the motion should have been laid in the answer , which was the right and privilege of libellee to do . It appears to the court that the enter- tainment of said motion would have granted the said prayer , for the reason stated therein ; and notwithstand- ing the issues already joined on other allegations , the cause would have been brought to an end without sub- stantial justice done , which would have worked injustice to the other party . It would have been lawful for libellee to have filed an amended answer setting forth new facts. (Lib . Stat . Chap . 5 , p . 26, sec . 6 ; p . 6, sec. 7. ) And further , the face of the writ directed to the marshal shows that the action instituted is one of a two -fold nature, an action in rem, and an action in personam . The marshal was directed to seize and safely keep said goods for further orders, and also to arrest the body of said appellant (then libellee ) . Evidently there is an action in rem and in personam . But if there were no