LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 267 This court says a verdict is the unanimous agreement of a petty jury as to facts submitted to them for deter- mination , and the dating or non - dating of it is a matter of form ; and that a verdict should not be set aside for want of form , as such defects are met by the rules and practice of courts , allowing such to be amended . Hence this exception is not well taken . Second, because the verdict rendered is contrary to the evidence , as the evidence failed to prove the allega- tions set forth in the complaint , but rather sustains the plea of justification set up in the answer of the appellant . This court is of opinion that this objection and exception is well taken , because "every party alleging the existence of a fact is required to prove the same , and also that the want of proof must defeat the best laid action , because facts , however logically set forth in a complaint , can never in law be accepted as proof , but must be sup- ported by evidence to warrant either a court or jury to consider such statement true, upon the principle that "every man is presumed to be innocent until he is proven guilty ." This action is founded in damages for an assault and battery unprovoked , and without any legal cause . The appellant pleads justification in whatever may have been his acts . Hence the plain duty of the court is to ascertain , from the record and testimony rendered in the court below , whether or not the verdict and judg- ment are supported by the law and the evidence rendered in the case . Having divested this case of all extraneous matter , we find the evidence as follows : D. W. Frazier , witness , stated as follows : "I did not see the affair between the plaintiff and defendant . I was at the defendant's place of business , the Norwegian's store . The defendant asked the chief manager to assist him to clear the store , as a row was coming . I heard Knowland say the defendant had kicked him ; this the