LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 381 In the case of the United States against McGlue (I Curtis U. S. C. C. Rep . ) the learned Judge Curtis remarked that there are undoubtedly persons of great general ability, filling important stations in life , who upon some one subject are insane ; and there are others whose minds are such that the conclusion of their reason and the result of their judgment are very far from being right. But , says he , it is not the business of the law to inquire into these peculiarities , but solely whether the accused was capable of having and did have a criminal intent . If he had , it punishes him , if not , it holds him unpunishable . And it supplies the test by which the jury is to ascertain whether the accused be so far insane as to be irresponsible . This court is of the opinion that there was strong and sufficient evidence produced at the trial , as already referred to by us , to show that the accused , at the time the crime was committed , was laboring under the delu- sion that people wanted to kill him and that his life was in imminent danger, and this fact, taken in connec- tion with the circumstances under which the homicide was committed , renders the offence excusable in law. The court below therefore erred in not awarding a new trial and in pronouncing sentence upon one whom it had been clearly shown was not sound in mind and memory . This court does not hesitate to declare its unwillingness to confirm a judgment of death where it appears that the homicide is excusable . It is better , observes Sir Mathew Hale , that ten guilty persons go unpunished than that one innocent person should be punished ; but how much more proper , is it not , that courts should in all cases acquit when the innocence of the accused is made apparent to it . The judgment of the court below is therefore reversed and the clerk of this court is hereby authorized to notify the judge of the court below of this decision . And for the public safety this court further directs that the said Samuel S. Ledlow , who has been made to