126 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS JAMES W. DRAPER and CHARLOTTE S. DRAPER , Appellants , vs. JAMES WILSON , CHARLOTTE HARRIS and BENJAMIN HARRIS , Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1880. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . Ejectment . Reply-Complaint-Mixed questions . 1. Where a reply is adjudged insufficient , judgment shall be given for the defendant ; where a reply is not filed within ten days after notice of the filing of the answer the plaintiff is presumed to rest upon the denial of the truth of the answer only, but where an indistinct or insuffi- cient reply is filed judgment shall be given for defendant . 2. A complaint which is indistinct with respect to the parties to a suit is bad . The ejectment in this case , which comes up on appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , was brought by the present appellants to recover possession of a certain piece of land , the title to which they claim has come to them as an estate of inheritance , etc. In reviewing the proceedings of this case , as presented by the record, we must remark that very few if any cases have come before us burdened with greater com- plications and legal mistakes than appear in this case . The first exception taken by the defendants is because the court below ruled "that the plaintiffs ' reply be abated , and they rely upon the grounds taken in their complaint ." The Supreme Court is of the opinion that the ruling of the court below on this first point , as set out in the bill of exceptions , is erroneous , and unwarranted by the statute and common law. Because if the court upon inspection had discovered the insufficiency of the reply , its duty was to have given judgment for the defendants . And no consideration whatever ought to have induced the court to apply any other principle to an insufficient