448 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS to begin , is one which has afforded a wide field for legal discussion and research . In the American courts the express enactments of the several states have declared what shall and what shall not be regarded as jeopardy in criminal prosecutions before the courts of the respec- tive states . And so divergent and technical are the shades of opinions expressed in these states upon this great subject, that a comparative study of them is ren- dered in a large degree perplexing , though exceedingly interesting and instructive . But it is the common law definition of the term jeopardy which interests us in the consideration of the case under review , and not the lex scripta of the Ameri- can states , and we shall therefore proceed to discuss the principles laid down on the point by some of the ablest and most profound common writers , whose works have been admitted as text -books in the courts of the Republic . And firstly , Mr. Bouvier defines jeopardy to be "The situation of a prisoner when a trial jury is sworn and empanelled to try his case upon a valid indict- ment , and such jury has been charged with his deliver- ance ." ( 1 Bouv . Law Dict . p . 751. ) Mr. Bishop in his treatise on criminal law confirms this view and enters into an exhaustive and minute treatment of the subject . We shall only quote here that part of his observations on jeopardy which applies to the case in point . "It appears ," he says , "a point not very clear on the authorities , that the keeping of the prisoner's legal rights is not at all with the jury, but only with the judge ; and that therefore if a juror of his own motive escapes so that no verdict can be rendered , such escape shows the prisoner never to have been in jeopardy . The same result would perhaps follow if the jury separated with the consent of the officer in attendance who had no right to give any consent ." "So it plainly must be," he continues , "if it should be found that a juror was legally incompetent to sit , or not sufficiently sworn , or