444 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS on this point as laid in the assignment of error, is to the taking and non -sealing of the depositions and not as to the legal right to use in evidence ex parte depositions in a case of this nature . This not having been raised in the pleadings and assignments , the court does not feel itself bound to pass upon it and therefore reserves opinion thereon . The third assignment is taken to the decree of the court below , delivered in the premises on the 25th day of May , 1904 , in which the libellee , now plaintiff in error, was adjudged guilty of piracy , and the following punish- ment inflicted ; namely , "That the libellee , now plaintiff in error , will make restitution of the stolen money £ 560, less the amount recovered by the government, and forfeit and pay to the government two hundred dollars ; and failing to pay said amount , he shall be imprisoned in the com- mon jail, with hard labor in chains, sufficiently long to pay said amount at the rate of six dollars per month ." Summing up the evidence produced at the trial , this court finds that the conclusions of the judge below upon the facts submitted are well and substantially founded . Independently of the depositions, whose admission as evidence was contested by the learned counsel for the libellee , now plaintiff in error , a strong and cogent case was made out by the prosecution , from the oral testi- mony put in evidence . But this court is obliged to announce that after a careful study of the statutes con- trolling this case it has failed to discover the law upon which the court below predicated that part of its decree relative to the punishment inflicted . Beyond a contro- versy the learned judge below mistook the law on this point . In an act defining piracy , found on the 145th page of the Compiled Statutes of Liberia , in Sec . 11 it is stated that "In all cases of conviction in any of the courts in this Republic of any of those crimes denominated by the law as piracy , to which no specific penalty has been