LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 379 Let us see by reference to the record whether sufficient evidence was produced at the trial to exclude every reasonable hypothesis as to the innocence of the accused ; secondly, whether the plea of insanity raised by the counsellor for the defense in his arguments , in excuse of the homicide , was supported at the trial by unim- peached evidence , and whether the plea is sufficient in law to excuse the prisoner ; thirdly , whether the prosecu- tion made out the sanity of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt ; fourthly , whether a person who is under an insane delusion as to existing facts , and com- mits an offence in consequence thereof , is thereby excusable ; and lastly, whether there were apparent grounds for setting aside the verdict of the jury and awarding a new trial . As to the first proposition , this court would remark that it has most carefully and scrutinizingly examined the whole evidence in this case , and has patiently applied the law governing evidence in such cases . From the testimony of the witnesses Coker , Moore and Porte there is proof that the accused was suffering from mental delusion on this particular point ; namely , that some person or persons , fancied in his mind , were seeking to take his life either by means of witchcraft or otherwise ; that the accused called at Coker's house three different times immediately before the day the crime was com- mitted , and that his conduct on these occasions was not that of one in a sound state of mind . Witness Porte testified that he had discovered the accused not to be in a sound state of mind about five years ago ; and he goes on to corroborate the strange conduct of the accused mentioned by witness Coker , which also led him to believe in the insanity of the prisoner . Witness Moore's statement is also very pertinent to the cause , first because of its scientific or professional character , and secondly on account of the direct knowledge which he claims to pos- sess , growing out of his diagnosis of the accused made