LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 119 was therefore no error in the court in ruling that "it had jurisdiction over the case." 3rd . That the question asked witness King , "Is the plaintiff the first and original discoverer of the process of congealing and preparing rubber and gutta percha ?" was irrelevant . This question was relevant, because it tended to prove one of the issues . 4th . The question asked witness D. B. Warner , "Do you know that India rubber and gutta percha have ever been prepared in and exported from this country , that was prepared according to the specifications attached to the letters patent before these letters patent were obtained by Mr. Moraes from the Liberian Govern- ment ?" was relevant for the same reason . 5th . The court erred in sustaining the objection to the admission of "Colling's Book on the Preparation of Caoutchouc ." Firstly , because our law provides that in seeking a patent the subject for which such right is to be obtained must not have been described in any book or publication in this country ; not that the book or publication must have been published in this country , but that the description is not to be in any book or publication that is in the country . And secondly, be- cause the book was relevant, tending to prove an issue . "If it be shown that an invention comprised in a patent was described in any published work or paper , or in any public records , before the date of the patent , the inven- tion was not then new as to the public knowledge of it, and therefore the patent is void ." (Hindmarch on Patents , p . 107. ) The book or publication presumes a knowledge of the invention by the public , or , what is the same thing, that it possessed the means of knowledge available to all . (Hindmarch , 457-8 . ) 6th . "That when defendant's attorney requested the court to charge the jury that the patent law of Liberia does not confer an exclusive right of export , the said court refused to so charge and said that it does grant an exclusive export right ."