488 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS ascertain the debt or the damages to be recovered from defendant . In all other actions of debt or replevin , and in all other contracts or damages it shall be the duty of the court , except as otherwise provided for , to cause the jury to ascertain the debt or damages . ( Lib . Stat . Chap . 16, secs . 9 and 10. ) The case as entered , whether legally so or not , as will be shown further on , is debt on an instrument of writing ; consequently , no jury had the right to ascertain the amount of debt, even had they brought in a verdict in favor of the plaintiff, now appellant , and the court erred in submitting the ascertainment of the debt to the jury . And if there was not sufficient evidence to sustain the cause in favor of the defendant , now appel- lee , the court should have so instructed the jury . In this respect the court erred, in that after the arguments in the case it was submitted by the court to the jury for a verdict , which verdict was found in favor of the defendant, now appellee, exonerating him of the debt claimed by plaintiff below . The plaintiff, now appellant , thereupon motioned the court for a new trial , which the court granted after hearing the arguments pro and con . On the 7th of July , 1905 , the new trial of the case began , but no written pleadings were allowed to be offered in the case by the court , upon the ground that the court had already passed on those pleadings in the first trial . That meant that the defendant's answer and demurrer were still held as ruled out , and the imper- fect judgment , based upon the ruling out of the defen- dant's answer, still held good in the new trial . The defendant offered in evidence the contract between him- self and the plaintiff, also his receipts for various amounts paid , that it might be proven that there was no specific debt otherwise than that growing out of the contract , and also to prove that the amount claimed by the plain- tiff had been paid by him , the defendant ; which evidence