68 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS having attentively examined the record , has arrived at the following conclusions :- Ist , That it was an error in the court below to com- pel the defendant to plead guilty or not guilty until it had been satisfied that there was no legal objection to the indictment , or other process against him. 2d, The court below also erred in admitting the testi- mony of D. R. Fletcher , to prove the charge of "false pretense and representation ." It is the opinion of this court that it is essentially necessary to establish the fact that a fraud or cheat had been committed , that the instrument of writing which is charged to have been obtained under false pretense , and by which means the fraud or cheat had been committed, should have been given in evidence ; for it is a settled rule of law that the best evidence the case admits of should be given in evi- dence . It was also error in the court below in refusing to grant the defendant a new trial ; because the record shows that the defendant had good cause to move for a new trial . No witness proved that the defendant had received any money or moneys under false pretense , or that there was any express or implied intent on the part of the defendant to do so. The record shows conclusively that the ver- dict of the jury is contrary to the evidence adduced . The court therefore adjudges that the judgment of the lower court be and the same is hereby reversed , and the appellant recover from the appellee all costs incurred .