LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 515 of said verdict and the justice of said final judgment which is founded thereon . All of which said appellees are ready to prove . Wherefore they pray the dismissal of said case with costs , as above stated . FENTON ANN HILL , O. G. R. HILL, and THOMAS S. HILL, Appellees , By their Counsellors , H. W. JOHNSON , JR ., and HY . W. GRIMES . COURT'S RULING . After reviewing the grounds set forth in appellees ' motion to dismiss this cause , the court is of opinion that where an appellant appeals from any decision rendered in a court below in favor of joint suitors , whether plaintiffs or defendants, the non-summoning of each individual of the said joint suitors to appear and answer the appeal, as appellees , is not fatal to the appeal . If one of said joint suitors has been summoned, it is sufficient notice to all , especially when one of the joint suitors in the court below appears in the court where the appeal is taken , and does an act which raises the presumption that said act was done by and with the consent and authority of the other joint appellees , as in this case , where the appellee , Fenton Ann Hill , makes affidavit to, and signs, the motion tendered this court to dismiss the case . And it is just for this court to conclude that her signing the motion referred to was to secure that advantage to all the appellees , and in doing so she acted by and with the consent and authority of the whole . Just here we would remark that without this view taken by the court the failure of each of the appellees to sign the motion ten- dered , to dismiss , would be equally as fatal as the non-summoning of each appellee , and consequently could not be countenanced by this court . Second , this court is of the opinion that the question referring to costs ought to have been raised and settled in the court below , or before the judge thereof . This court is authorized to examine matters in dispute upon the record only , therefore it can notice no question to which the attention of the court below does not appear to have been called by the bill of exceptions or other rec- ords ; and this court is of opinion that the court below would not grant an appeal before the law has been complied with, and until the contrary appears on the record this court must regard the plea , in this particular , insufficient to support the motion . Thirdly , in the examination of the bill of exceptions it is obvi- ous that the opinions and statements therein made and cited respecting certain rulings said to have been made by the court below , tend to lead the mind of this court into a state of conjec-