LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 443 town they happen to occur , and that the law of civilized states will not punish one who converts private property to his personal use under such circumstances ? It would seem in this particular case , that even if there had not existed that rule of law in admiralty prac- tice , upon which the learned judge acted in refusing to dismiss the suit , he would have been justified in the course he adopted by the stern reasons of public policy and transparent justice . We proceed next to consider the second assignment , which is taken to the court's admitting as evidence depositions taken by a justice of the peace , in a case of larceny , against the plaintiff in error , for the same act which constitutes the subject of this suit. The grounds laid are : ( 1 ) "That the said depositions were not taken by the deponent nor the Justice of the Peace , but by his clerk " ; and ( 2 ) "that they were presented unsealed ." As to the first ground , we fail to see the reason of it. It appears from the second , that the depositions were properly taken before a Justice of the Peace and that they were signed in the legal form by the deponent . The mere fact that they were recorded by the magis- trate's clerk and not by the magistrate himself , cannot impeach their genuineness and validity ; especially so when, as we have said , they were signed by the witnesses who made the statements , and a jurat in legal form signed by the Justice of the Peace before whom they were taken , which is prima facie evidence of their validity. As to the second ground , this court is of opinion that the simple fact that the depositions were presented at the trial unsealed , but which fact is unconnected with any circumstance tending to show that they had been tampered with , or that they had in any respect been altered , was not , in the opinion of this court , sufficient ground for the court below to have ruled them out. It should be strictly observed , however , that the exception