404 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS capacity as experts , or derived from the statements of writers of medical or surgical works . (II Bouv. Law Dict . p . 171 : "Medical Evidence .") It was insisted by the attorney for the prosecution in the court below , that the witness having for a long time practiced medicine and having also served the State in a military expedition , as physician , this was evidence of his general character as a medical man . We cannot agree with this contention. The fact that witness had practiced as a medical man for a considerable time does not, in the opinion of this court, establish the fact of his qualification as a physician , to enable him to depose to matters of medical science . It is not prima facie evidence of his qualification as such . There is no evidence in the record to show that witness proved he held a diploma or certificate from any medical college or institution to this effect . The record , rather , shows the contrary . It is therefore the opinion of this court that witness Tate was not such a person as the law regards as competent to give evidence as a medical expert in a trial for murder . The court below therefore erred in admitting said witness as a medical expert. Passing over the fourth point in the bill of exceptions , which we do not deem essential to our conclusions in the case , we now proceed to consider the fifth and sixth points in said bill . From further inspection of the record we find that the jury having returned a verdict of guilt against the prisoners, their counsel tendered a motion , praying the judge of the court below to award prisoners a new trial , on the ground that said verdict was contrary to the law and evidence in the case ; which motion the court below overruled , and subsequently , that is to say, on the 4th day of April , 1902 , pronounced sentence against the prisoners . We feel no hesitancy in saying that there was a palpable misapplication of the law on evidence by the court below . We have examined with consider-