LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 165 Witness also states that he recognized the signature on the document handed him as being J. B. McGill's for McGill & Bro. , and the signature of the witness to the document as being Wm . Thompson's , and the body of the writing to be J. B. McGill's . He also states that the other partners of the firm were , Doctor McGill , R. S. McGill of Cape Palmas , and J. B. McGill, but was not cer- tain as to the admission of Rockey McGill into the firm . Witness Howard states that J. B. McGill was the sur- viving partner of the firm of McGill & Bro. He also states that all the parties referred to in connection with the firm except J. B. McGill were dead in January, 1880 . The written evidence of the plaintiff was then put in : Ist, the deed from James B. McGill and Martha his wife to McGill & Bro.; 2nd , the note of hand given by J. B. McGill in the name of said firm ; after which , the said defendants presented a note published in the "Observer ." Having noticed the evidence introduced by the parties. in the case , we shall now consider how they go to prove or disprove the alleged debt . The first issue , then , is whether the written instru- ment upon which the action of debt is brought is suffi- cient in law to bind the legal representatives of the firm of McGill & Bro . We are of opinion it is not ; because it is clearly proven by witness J. W. Howard , that in January , A. D. 1880 , all the partners of the firm of McGill & Bro . were dead except James B. McGill, who was the surviving partner at the time the note of hand was given the appellee . And it does appear from the question put by the plaintiff in the court below to wit- nesses C. T. O. King and J. W. Howard , as to whether J. B. McGill was or was not the surviving partner of the firm of McGill & Bro. , that the appellee was not ignorant of the fact that J. B. McGill could not at the time of the making of this note of hand legally bind the legal repre- sentatives of the deceased partners, whose death oper- ated as a dissolution of the partnership .