268 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS defendant denied , and charged the plaintiff with being in his way . I saw no signs of injury done ." H. W. Brooks , Jr. , says : "I saw the plaintiff below , and Daniel Beal , at the time mentioned in the complaint , sitting on the steps leading into the store of the Nor- wegian . I saw when the appellant came to the door , stood between them, and shoved them off ; before this he told them twice to move . Knowland asked , Why did he shove him from the steps ? He , the defendant , answered , You are in my way ." Samuel Ferguson states that at the time laid in the complaint , he was present , and that the plaintiff and Beal were sitting on the steps leading to the store of defendant . The defendant asked them , "What are you hanging round my store for?" Plaintiff looked up at him and went on talking . Defendant came up to the steps again and asked the same question ; receiving no reply , he stood between them and said , "Excuse me ." They did not move . Then with his feet he sidewise shoved them both off the steps . He thought the defen- dant was protecting his premises . Daniel Beal says he and the plaintiff were much in liquor , sitting on the steps and talking very loud about the war at Palmas ; that they annoyed traders in the store . The defendant below came to the door and asked , "What are you doing here ?" They gave no answer . He came again and eased them off the steps . Had they not been in liquor it would not have happened . As to damages and injury , he does not know that plain- tiff was injured ; he was not . C. B. Scotland knew nothing about the plaintiff being injured or damaged by the defendant . This closes the testimony bearing on the case . From the evidence it is clear to the mind of the court that while it shows that the defendant did shove plain- tiff with his feet from off the steps of the defendant's store , or place where he was employed , yet we are of