LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 231 verdict, he found that some of the jurors were not satis- fied , that the calculations in the verdict already made up by their clerk were correct , and that he took a sepa- rate piece of paper and added up the figures of their clerk , and said to their clerk , "It is right." This fact is a most fatal feature to the verdict , and yet we do not dwell here to establish so great a wrong . See Liberia Statute , first book , 9th chapter , 10th section , and see how positive the rule of law is on this point . The law abhors any interference with a jury after they have retired for deliberation . The act of D. E. Howard entering the petit jury's room , and calculating for them, does not at first glance present a favorable phase . Both Howard and the jury violated the law most flagrantly . Howard entering the jury room and not knowing whether he was called there or went there himself , and conversed with one of the jury on the subject which they had under their deliberation , and concerning which some of them were dissatisfied , is a grave matter . How much was said or done during the interview Howard had with the jury is still a mystery , for neither Howard nor the jury could legally give evidence to excuse or justify them- selves . The violation of such a positive law of the land , which so strictly enjoined them to keep themselves together and converse with no one before they have rendered a verdict , should have had the careful and strictest attention of the court below ; such violations left unnoticed may lead to the most direful infringements on the rights and liberties of litigants . Sixth . Lastly , we say the refusal of a new trial in the court below was an error ; for it is an admitted fact that a verdict of a questionable character will cause irregu- larities in the proceedings , but a suspicious one needs legal help itself . Therefore , considering the cause set forth in the defendants' motion below for a new trial , we are of opinion that the court ought to have granted it. Therefore it is adjudged by this court that the judg- ment of the lower court is reversed , and this case is