LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 495 ing false, slanderous and defamatory words ; that is to say, that the plaintiffs made a claim upon the insurance. company for the loss of twenty logs , which twenty logs the plaintiffs had already made the Cavalla natives pay them for ; thereby meaning that the plaintiffs ' claim against the insurance company was false and fraudulent , and thereby meaning that the plaintiffs have received money under false pretence , by means of which the plaintiffs have been brought into public scandal and disgrace, and their business reputation greatly injured as well as their character , fame and good name ." The complaint of plaintiffs , now appellees , setting forth the offence alleged to have been committed against them by the defendant, now appellant , embracing the instrument of libel , was in the court below rebutted by the defendant's answer , upon the ground , first , "that the complaint is ambiguous in that it charges the said defendant with two separate forms of action ; that is to say, libel and slander ; which is contrary to the rule of pleadings . The said plaintiff in said complaint ought to have chosen one particular form of action against the said defendant to enable him to make a proper defence to same ," etc. Secondly , he avers that his communication to the British Consul comes under the head of all those com- munications that are made bona fide in the performance of a duty , whether public or private , or with a fair and reasonable purpose of protecting the interests of the party to whom they are made , or of the interests of both in a matter in which they are mutually interested ; such communications are held to be excusable in law from the consequences which may follow . As to this last point , the evidence in this case fails to show any relationship of the defendant, now appellant , with the British Consul thereby excusing him from writing , publishing and circulating the libellous letter constituting the grounds of the complaint .