LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 465 ceive the vast amount of inconvenience and injustice which a defendant would be subjected to if the rule was less inflexible . Here, in the case under our consideration , the plain- tiffs , now appellees, set up a claim to a specific lot or parcel of land , distinctly set forth and described in the declaration . In the deed offered as prima facie evidence of said claim , there appear none of the boundaries and descriptions mentioned in the declaration , which , in our opinion , was absolutely necessary in order to prove that the property claimed in the declaration is identical with that mentioned in the deed offered as evidence , as having been granted unto their ancestors , under whom they claim , by the rule of descent . A disagreement in these very essential points rendered the deed irrelevant to the issue and at variance with the facts laid and pleaded in the declaration . The seventh , eighth and ninth exceptions , which we deem worthy of consideration , are taken to the court below rejecting as evidence offered on the part of the defendants , now appellants , the transfer titles for the property in question , first from Moriah Hatland to Samuel Toliver , and from Samuel and Jane Toliver to Lucinda Scotland , and from E. and John Allen Scotland , heirs of Lucinda Scotland , to appellants . Beyond a doubt the lower court committed a gross error in rejecting as evidence the above mentioned con- veyances , beginning with Moriah Harland to Samuel Toliver , and by a long line of transfers down to appel- lants , by virtue of which succession of titles made from time to time and openly held and enjoyed by the privies of appellants for more than forty years , which appel- lants sought to establish as their special plea in bar of the appellees' claim . It was imperative for the appel- lants in support of their plea , to prove that the property in dispute had been openly held and enjoyed either by themselves or their privies , under a color of right and