76 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS of this motion having been argued by the counsel on both sides , the court below ruled that the motion to dismiss the case had not been sustained ; and ordered the same to trial . And as a reason for its ruling , says the law does not make it the duty of appellee to give the appellant a copy of the account filed : and therefore the appellee cannot be made to suffer on account of the appel- lant obtaining an incorrect copy from the clerk . The ruling of the court below upon this motion is correct . We shall now proceed to the second exception under con- sideration by this court . The question was asked witness John R. Freeman , comptroller , by the appellant's counsel : "Has at any time within the last two years the correct- ness of your bookkeeping been questioned in the treas- ury department ?" This was objected to by the appel- lee's counsel , and the objection was sustained by the court below . This ruling was an error of the court , because the witness was comptroller , an officer con- nected with the treasury department , whose duty it was to examine and to see that correct accounts of all public officers were kept, and that proper and lawful entries were made of the same . For it does not alter the case , whether the comptroller came into that office after the transaction of Robert R. Johnson as treasurer had taken place, or before ; because the law supposes that the records or entries , properly kept, are evidence of all public transactions . The third exception we have noticed , is that taken to the ruling of the court below upon the objection made by appellee's counsel to the question put to witness H. W. Dennis , secretary of the treasury , by appel- lant's counsel : "Was this suit brought at your instance ?" Upon the objection made to this question , the court ruled that it is sustained , which ruling is correct , because the question is irrelevant and involves an independent issue , which can be entertained only when tendered in a special plea, or upon a motion properly made before the court .