LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 413 Customs, by the attorney for the defence , as follows : "Did Mr. West , the appellant , apply to your office for a permit ?" To this query the witness replied , "I am not positive ; if he did , I refused him ." It was also given in evidence by the wharfinger that appellant's clerk offered him , previous to shipping as aforesaid, the fee charged for permits , which fee he , the wharfinger , refused to accept , upon the ground that he had received instruc- tions from the Collector of Customs not to allow appel- lant to ship . It was also stated in evidence by the same witness , that it was customary for appellant to pay him the fee charged for permits , and that the Collector of Customs had on previous occasions accepted the same from him in favor of appellant for permits . The evi- dence further shows that appellant sent his clerk to the customs department prior to shipping as aforesaid , and that the Collector was not there in his office . And further , it was stated that the said produce , excepting the coffee , was shipped under the eye and with the knowledge of the wharfinger . From the circumstances surrounding this case , as well as the light thrown on it by the prosecution's own wit- nesses , this court is firmly of the opinion that the charge alleged against the appellant was not substantially proved at the trial , and this court has vainly sought to discover the evidence and the law upon which the decree of the court below is founded . The judgment of the court below is therefore reversed and the clerk of this court is hereby authorized to issue a mandate informing the judge of the court below of this decision .