390 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS dissatisfied with the verdict of the jury , which she con- sidered to be manifestly against the law and evidence in the case , motioned the court below for a new trial , which the said court granted , to be held at the same session of the court . The case was tried de novo , and a second jury gave verdict in favor of the plaintiff, now defendant in error , to which defendants objected and motioned the court for arrest of judgment , which the court would not sustain , assigning as a reason that the ground of the motion was not what the law requires for the arrest of judgment , and proceeded to render final judg- The defendants , now plaintiffs in error , believing that injustice had been done to them, and being dis- pleased with the verdict of the jury, and considering the various rulings and the judgment of the court as errone- ous , brought the case up to this court on an assignment of errors , that they may be corrected (if any there are ) , and substantial justice given . The assignment of errors consists of ten counts , but the court will only pass on those which are sufficient to determine the case , they being more pertinent . The first assignment is as follows : "Because on the four- teenth day of May , A. D. 1901 , when the case was called up , the defendants , now plaintiffs in error , gave notice to the court that they had a motion to offer to dismiss plaintiff's action , but the court ruled that the plaintiff had a right to offer a motion first ." On this point this court says the judge below erred in his ruling , and is of the opinion that the party who pleads last has the right, legally, to motion the court to dismiss . The rule of court granting to plaintiff the right to begin and close all pleadings , does not preclude the defendants from petitioning the court to dismiss a cause for manifest error in the pleading , provided the defendant is in a position to move first , for it is evident that the plaintiff will not motion for the dismissal of his own cause . In the case under review the defendants,