196 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS the case is not yet in a condition to be heard and deter- mined and there can , of course , be no valid judgment rendered ." The statute directs the manner in which the court or judge shall proceed , when the person to whom the writ is directed appears and does not produce the body of the prisoner . ( See Lib . Statute , Book I , page 67 , sec . 8. ) But nothing is said as to what course should be pursued if, upon the return of the duplicate writ , the court or judge should be informed that the person to whom the writ is directed cannot be found , nor the prisoner he has in his custody . I now ask, under such circum- stances what should the court or judge do ? Why, cer- tainly the court or judge should exercise discretion , this being an inherent right of a court of law . This is just what I have done , and was fully warranted by the Con- stitution and law to do , because after the return of the writ of habeas corpus there must be some action on it by the court or judge . The Constitution gives wide jurisdiction to the court , as to how freely the prisoner may be allowed to enjoy the benefit of a writ of habeas corpus , as also does the law. Every judgment delivered on it is valid , because the law has exempted such judgment from the review of any court , as I have shown in the preceding comments . We now consider the last position taken by the Attor- ney General , which reads as follows :- "Without , however , entering at length into this ques- tion , and considering only the stage of the case at which said judgment was given , and the fact that the law officers of the Republic were not notified to appear and defend its interests , I feel it my duty to say that , in my opinion , you ought not to pay said bill of costs ." Here I hesitate not to say that there is no rule of court that exempts the Government from the payment of any costs incurred in a case brought for a public offence and crime . Nor is there any principle of law applicable to