278 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS number thirty -three , formerly styled number thirty - six , unless otherwise determined by law, and that the plaintiff recover from the defendants all legal costs in this action ." The opinion of the court on this point is that the judge below erred ; for in the first part of the decree the judge said that he could not consider the question of validity of titles, or the matter of quiet enjoyment, which is collateral , both parties claiming said land under deeds from the Republic of Liberia . This court is at a loss to know by what parity of legal reasoning did the judge decree that the defendants , now appellants , be forever enjoined and prohibited from intermeddling , or annoying and harrassing said plaintiff in the cultivation of his twenty acres of farm land situated on Po River , and bearing number thirty -three, formerly styled number thirty-six . And this court further says that the judge below erred in said decree by enjoining a perpetual injunction on defendants , now appellants , which , in the opinion of this court , is virtually deciding the validity of titles . In this equity case the irregularity of the proceedings of the court below are so much opposed to equity and good conscience as to lead this court to the following determination : This court adjudges that the decree of the court below is hereby reversed and the injunction dissolved, and that appellants recover all costs in this appeal case from appellee . The clerk is hereby com- manded to issue a mandate to the court from whence this case came , informing it of this decree .