LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 229 A. D. WILLIAMS , surviving partner of the firm of A. D. Williams & Bro ., Appellant, vs. R. LEWIS & CO. , Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1890. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Bond-Subsequent pleadings of a defendant after answer- Counter -claims or set-offs-Account . 1. Where a bond varies from the general principles of law relating thereto, it will produce an irregularity in the proceedings although filed by an attorney on behalf of his client. 2. The subsequent pleadings by a defendant after the answer, are governed by the same rules as those which , by statute , the answer is subject to . 3. An account presented as a set -off in debt is evidence of a counter- claim, though not conclusive. 4. Where a jury allows one outside of its panel to assist in making up its verdict , it is an irregularity which is good ground for a new trial , and where a new trial is refused , and judgment is rendered on such verdict , it will be ground for reversal of said judgment . This case upon the transcript of record as sent up from the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions for Montserrado County , presents many complications and irregularities in the court below which have had our most careful consideration , and now we have arrived at a conclusion founded upon the principles of law and justice . First . As to appellant's first exception we are of opinion that when an attorney for his client executes a bond under the rule of court , and the bond so executed varies from the general principles of law, the court will not give it support , but rather regard it as an irregu- larity in the proceedings . Second . In respect to the second exception , we are of opinion that every pleading to the plaintiff (after the first ) is in the nature of an answer within the meaning of the statute , and is subject to the rules governing the The court below did not err in striking defen- dants ' rejoinder off the file . ( See Liberia Statutes , Book 1, Chap. 5 and 6.) same .