LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 437 bill being bad in part , should have been by said equity court adjudged bad as to the whole , and therefore dis- missed . Therefore the decree made in this case by the court below is hereby reversed and made void and of no effect , and the appellees shall pay all legal costs of the appeal . And the clerk of this court is hereby directed to issue a mandate to the court below as to this judgment ; also directing him to immediately place the partners as they were before said decree . J. G. MONTGOMERY , Appellant , vs. WILLIAM ZEISER , Agent for J. W. West , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1905. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County . Appearance-Imperfect judgment —Final judgment . A communication by a defendant's attorney addressed to the clerk of the trial court requesting him to enter an appearance , amounts to a formal appearance if made within the time fixed by law . Where the statute provides that upon rendering an imperfect judg- ment the court shall proceed to render final judgment , it is grossly irregular to proceed to trial without a jury. After rendition of a final judgment , a case cannot be reopened by the trial court and another judgment rendered , although in conformity with the previous judgment . This is an appeal from the ruling and judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Grand Bassa County , at its December term , 1903. From the transcript of the record to this court , it appears that appellant did enter into a mercantile agreement with the appellee during the month of May , 1903 , to the effect that the appellee was to supply the appellant with goods or merchandise , thereby enabling him to open trade and exchange said goods for marketable African produce , and that the appellee did supply the goods as agreed . The record shows further , that the appellant on his part also promised and agreed to "deliver to the appellee all