LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 519 J. J. ROSS , Plaintiff in Error , vs. RUSSELL MINUS , Defendant in Error . Damages . [January Term , A. D. 1884.] Before His Honor C. L. Parsons , Chief Justice , and the Honorable Associate Justices , Henry J. Neyle and Z. B. Roberts . MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL . Russell Minus , defendant in the above entitled cause , respect- fully motions this honorable court to dismiss this case and to rule the plaintiff to pay costs , first , because the plaintiff in error has failed to file in this court a complete record ; as the original deed from the Republic of Liberia to S. H. Crayton , and a transfer deed from S. H. Crayton to Russell Minus , for the remnant lot alleged to be appurtenant to lot No. 58, in Greenville , Sinoe County , part of the written evidence in the above entitled cause , can nowhere be found in the record filed in the office of the clerk of this honorable court . Second, and also because the above entitled cause was brought into this court before the rendition of the final judgment in said case , by the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas of the County of Grand Bassa , as will appear by the record filed in the office of the clerk of this honorable court . Respectfully submitted , RUSSELL MINUS , By J. NANSTEDLAW LEWIS and Arthur BARCLAY , Counsellors at Law . COURT'S RULING. This was an action of damages , tried in the Court of Quarter Sessions of Grand Bassa County , at its September term , A. D. 1883 , and upon a writ of error was brought up to this court for review . In this case the defendant in error submits for the con- sideration of this court a motion to dismiss the case , first , because the record is incomplete ; second , because certain deeds used as evidence of the defendant's title in the court below have not been sent up as a part of the record in this case . Upon inspection of the record the court finds that a verdict has been returned by the jury in favor of the defendant , to which the plaintiff took exceptions ; but for some cause which does not appear on the record , the exceptions were not allowed . So it was on account of this , and also because the defendant was allowed to withdraw certain deeds used as evidence at the trial of the cause ,