LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 55 W. S. ANDERSON , Appellant , vs. H. W. DENNIS , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1872.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Where the bill of exceptions in an appeal is unsigned by the lower judge , the Appellate Court will not hear the appeal unless it appears that the judge neglected or refused to sign the same . Counsel W. M. Davis for the appellee filed a motion to dismiss the case on the ground that there is no legal bill of exceptions before the court , as the bill filed with the record is not signed by the judge of the lower court as the law directs . This question has been already decided in the case of the Southern Baptist Mission vs. McGill Bro ., January term , A. D. 1861 , that this court cannot consider any case of appeal legally before it unless upon a bill of exceptions duly signed by the judge of the court from which the appeal is taken . The court finds that the bill of exceptions in this case is not signed . It is due to the judge who tried the case to say that there appears no evidence to show that he either neglected or refused to sign the bill of exceptions ; it is therefore the fault of the appellant . Therefore , the court decides that the case be dismissed , and the clerk is hereby commanded to issue a mandate to the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , informing it of this decision ; appellant to pay all costs incurred in the court .