LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 127 reply, but that embraced in the fifth section of the law on the 27th page of Liberia Statute , Book 1 . When the plaintiff fails to reply to the defendant's answer within ten days after he has notice that it is filed , the law directs that he shall be obliged to rest his case on the denial of the truth of the answer only ; but when the reply is not distinct , intelligible and sufficient , judgment shall be given for the other party . The second exception is to the ruling of the court below, to the effect that the plaintiffs ' complaint is sufficiently distinct and intelligible . On inspection of the complaint , this court finds a want of distinctness therein in respect to the names of the plaintiffs in this action . In the same complaint it is made to appear that one Charlotte Harris is the wife of Benjamin Harris , and also that one Charlotte Wilson is the wife of Benja- min Harris , and that both of these females , together with James Wilson and Benjamin Harris , are plaintiffs . Charlotte Harris is set out as one of the surviving heirs at the commencement of the complaint , but at the con- clusion thereof Charlotte Wilson's name is substituted . Now the question as to whether Charlotte Harris is the same person called Charlotte Wilson , or whether they are two separate persons , ought to have been distinctly set out. The complaint must be distinct and intelligible so as to enable the court to know for or against whom it should give its decree or judgment . To guard , there- fore , this principle of the law , the court says the court . below erred in ruling that the complaint was sufficient . The third exception is taken to the court proceeding to try a mixed question before the questions of law contained in defendants ' answer were disposed of ; but the question referred to not being stated or laid in said . exception , the court will not give any expression with regard thereto . As to the fourth exception , to the court ruling that the third point in defendants ' answer was a question of law ,