LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 303 court . favor of the City of Buchanan , and from that decree the libellee (now appellant ) took exceptions and tendered the necessary bill for the signature of the judge of said. The judge denied , or refused to sign , the libellee's bill of exceptions , and upon a petition to this court a writ of mandamus was issued , requiring the judge of the court below to sign the bill of exceptions so that the libellee could obtain an appeal , or show legal cause for not doing so at the January term of the court , A. D. 1895 . During the January term of this court, A. D. 1896 , the judge of the court below made his return to the man- damus ; but the same being unanimously declared unsatis- factory and insufficient , this court issued a peremptory mandamus on the judge of the court below , to which absolute demand no return has reached this court . In the month of November last the nation was startled by the information of the death of Hon . W. Brumskin , judge of the court below-the Court of Common Pleas and Quarter Sessions , Grand Bassa County . At the calling of the case on the fourth day's session of this court of the present term , the court discovers that no record of any description (save the petition for the writ of mandamus , the insufficient return of the judge of the court below , and the peremptory mandamus ) is in the possession of the court . This court has carefully examined the several decisions rendered by it from the foundation of the Republic and has discovered only one case bearing any affinity to the present , which decision was rendered in 1865 , in the case of N. J. A. Maarschalk against the Republic of Liberia , and which reads as follows : "This court decides that the record of the court below is incomplete , one or more essential documents being absent . The Compiled Statutes , page 61 , sec . 5 , require that the entire record shall be forwarded to the court of appeal . In consequence of this ommission this court rules that the case cannot be considered , and is therefore dis-