454 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS witness states that in the afternoon of the same day the crime was committed , he saw prisoner on the road to Careysburg , under circumstances which appear to the court very suspicious . He further states that prisoner had with him a gun . Witness Mulbar's testimony , when taken together with the other witnesses ' , removes much of the doubt which otherwise would have surrounded the case. It is the last link of a long chain of evidence , which enabled the law to finally trace the crime to prisoner . Without Mulbar's testimony it would have been difficult to connect the former acts and admissions of prisoner , which laid the foundation for strong pre- sumption , and his flight from the officer and other sus- picious conduct , with the actual commission of the crime charged. The voluntary confession of the prisoner to witness Mulbar , under circumstances which excluded the idea of its having been made under duress , or threat , or fear , or inducement , established a strong case for the prose- cution , the corpus delicti having been proven by inde- pendent testimony . Taking witness Mulbar's statement , which proves the confession of prisoner to the alleged crime , together with the presumptive and circumstantial proof submitted , we feel no hesitancy in asserting that the guilt of the accused has been made out with legal certainty . It was the privilege of the prisoner to have rebutted this evidence and thereby raise a rational doubt as to his guilt , which doubt , if well founded , would have operated in his favor . But we find that this was not even attempted . Traversing the whole evidence with a determination to discover whatever could be discovered therein , in prisoner's favor , we have found not the slightest foundation upon which to predicate his inno- cence . It was insisted upon by the learned counsel for the accused , in his arguments , that prisoner was not in the settlement of Bensonville at the time of the commission