378 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS based upon his scientific knowledge as a regularly quali- fied physician , his opinion on the general nature and description of that disease of the mind called in medical jurisprudence dementia accidentalis , which disease , in one of its forms , the accused alleged he was affected with . This witness further stated that the accused had been under his treatment prior to the time when the homicide was committed , and that the diagnosis made in his particular case revealed the fact that the accused was suffering from some mental derangement which rendered him insane in a degree . This testimony was of vast importance to the case and , unless impeached by strong rebutting evidence , ought to have been re- ceived with a considerable degree of weight . So too with the testimony of Coker , which , although not com- ing from a medical man , was nevertheless pertinent to the case , because it revealed facts concerning the strange , uncustomary actions of the accused , shortly before the commission of the crime charged ; which evidence , taken with that of Dr. Moore , would tend to enable the jury to determine whether or not the agent of the crime was such a person as the law would fix responsibility upon . The testimony of Moore and Coker was essentially rele- vant, as were also the questions propounded to them by the counsellor for the defence and ruled out by the court below . This court is firmly of the opinion that the judge of the court below erred in ruling out the said questions . ( Lib . Stat . Bk . 1, Chap . 12 , secs . I and 32 ; I Arch . Crim . Prac. and Pleadings , pp . 33 , 34. ) We proceed next to consider the ninth and tenth exceptions laid in the appellant's bill of exceptions , upon which exceptions the case chiefly hangs . In these ex- ceptions the appellant maintains that his guilt was not made out by the State at the trial with that certainty required by law, and that therefore the court below ought to have granted him a new trial , upon the ground that the verdict was manifestly against the evidence .