324 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS its trial in the said court below , occasioned no little excitement and criticism , favorable and unfavorable . But this court , recognizing its responsibility as the chief and final legal resort of the country , and having due regard and high respect for the majesty of the law , which is not only the rule for the conduct of the court but also that for the civil and political conduct of all citizens , will proceed to review the case and come to its conclusion , in all good conscience , regardless of smiles or frowns . It shall be our duty, first , to treat upon the most important and reasonable points of the bill of exceptions , and see how far they are sustained by the law and evidence governing the case , and to conclude on the same . The appellant excepts to the rulings , opinions and decisions , as well as to the final decree of the judge below , first , "Because when , on the 26th day of February , 1897 , libellee submitted a motion to your Honor for restora- tion of certain goods therein named , and after argu- ments pro and con , your Honor refused the libellee's prayer contained in said motion , to which libellee excepts ." On that point the judge below ruled as follows : "The court , after hearing the arguments pro and con , is of the opinion that the matter set forth in the said motion in admiralty practice partakes of the nature of excep- tions, and the said libellee having filed a first and a second answer to the libel , should have raised and specially pleaded the matter set forth in said answers ; and his neglecting to do so is laches on his part , and the court could not at this stage of the proceedings admit the same to be pleaded , on the motion offered by said libellee . Therefore , the court rules that the motion is insufficient and it cannot sustain the same , as the parties are now confined to the issues relied on in the several pleadings filed in the office of the clerk of this court ." This court will now proceed to consider whether the