LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 71 June , 1873 , by the appellee , Charles Batam (plaintiff in the court below ) , and was removed February , 1873 , upon a change of venue , as provided for by the statutes , to the Court of Quarter Sessions of Maryland County for trial ; and from which it is brought here upon a bill of exceptions for review . This case presents many complications . This court , however , by the application of well -settled principles of law, has been enabled to unravel all of them and deter- mine for whom judgment ought to be given . The statute declares that all actions except injunctions and replevins shall be commenced by a writ of summons directed to the sheriff, requiring him to summon the defendant to appear at a day appointed to answer the plaintiff's com- plaint. The writ, with the return of the sheriff endorsed thereon that he has summoned the defendant , is the evidence the law requires as proof that the defendant has been summoned ; this not appearing upon the record in the case to have been done , the motion of the defen- dant in the court below to dismiss the action is well grounded , and therefore ought to have been sustained , and the court erred in ruling to the contrary . For it must be remembered that a neglect to serve any original process , by which means only an action of law could be commenced, is a default that cannot be cured by the application of any principles of law . And the court says mind to convince it it requires but very little exercise of of the fact that such a neglect as referred to differs vastly from a defect in the process itself , that may be cured by the appearance and answer of the defendant . The court below ruled or decided that the defendant is estopped , by the oath he made for the change of venue , from his legal rights and privileges . Now if the con- struction placed upon the law providing for a change of venue by the court below was correct , the very object of its creation would be defeated , as must be plainly For the intention of the Legislature in making the seen.