222 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS SIMON ATTIA , Appellant, vs. ROBERT T. SHER- MAN , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1889. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Damages . 1. In an action for damages , evidence of debt or fraud arising from some business transaction or book accounts , is irrelevant ; the proof must conform with the action chosen . 2. Where an agent is given power to sell goods at such prices as may become necessary , from the fluctuations of the market, he cannot after- wards be charged with violating the original contract with respect to prices , unless it appears that he acted fraudulently . 3. Where account books are intended to be used in evidence they must be identified as the books of the party or firm introducing them . This is an appeal from the proceedings and judgment of the Court of Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , at its September term , 1887. The action was brought by the appellant , plaintiff below , for the violation of a contract . At the trial , defendant below ( now the appel- lee ) obtained judgment , the same being based upon the verdict of a jury unto whom the facts were submitted ; from which judgment and other proceedings , exceptions were taken by the plaintiff below , and upon the excep- tions thus taken the case is brought up for review . The exceptions taken are : 1, Because the court refused to allow witness S. E. F. Cadogan to answer the question , " What did the defendant charge you for the plank ?" upon the objection of the defendant below that the question was irrelevant to the issue . 2, Because the court allowed witness T. W. Haynes to answer the ques- tion , " Will you explain to the court what is this over- plus ?" ( of which witness had spoken ,) upon the ground that such an answer would be an opinion and not evi- dence in this case . 3, Because the court admitted as evidence a letter marked number 28 , the same , in the opinion of the plaintiff below , had no tendency to estab-