LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 89 together with the opinion or reason of the court for not entertaining the same. The refusal of the court to reduce its opinion to writing is a denial of a legal right , and an obstruction against the regular mode of obtaining an appeal . And for these reasons this court says the court below erred in refusing to hear the motion in arrest of judgment , and also in refusing to reduce its opinion to writing . A party waiving his right to a new trial does not bar him- self of a right to an arrest of judgment ; because it is a well - settled principle that a waiver of one legal right does not debar one from resorting to another . Therefore , this court adjudges that the judgment rendered in the case above mentioned , in the Court of Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , against the said Walter Brown , agent for A. Warmann , of Hamburg , plaintiff in error , in said action of damages for the viola- tion of a written contract is hereby reversed , set aside and made void and of no legal effect whatever ; and that the said plaintiff in error recover from the said F. · J. Grant , defendant in error , his costs in this action . THOMAS CASSELL , Appellant , vs. MATILDA RICHARDSON , Appellee . [ January Term , A. D. 1876. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Statute of Limitation - Written evidence - New trial . A plea specially pleading the Statute of Limitation in bar to a suit is a question purely of law , and by statute must be determined by the court , independent of a jury . Where a written instrument is offered in evidence , it should form a part of the record , even though it be not admitted as evidence , in order that the appellate court , upon an appeal , may ascertain whether it is proper evidence or not . This case is sent up from the Court of Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , upon a bill of exceptions .