LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 405 able diligence the evidence produced at the trial by the prosecution , but have failed to discover such legal evi- dence as could warrant the jury in arriving at the con- clusion of guilt . It is a well settled principle in criminal law, that "every one is presumed to be innocent until the contrary is proven ." It is also an established rule , that the onus probandi , or burden of proof , rests upon him who maintains the affirmative , and although there are instances where the burden of proof shifts , as where the prisoner attempts to justify, the case under con- sideration does not fall within the exception to the general rule . And , says Mr. Archbold , where the plea of the defendant is "not guilty," the prosecution must prove defendant guilty of the charge before the latter can be called upon for his defence . (I Arch . Crim . Pleadings , p . 359. ) And the prosecution must prove it beyond a rational doubt . In civil cases the jury may decide according to the preponderance of evidence , but in criminal cases-cases affecting life or liberty — the evi- dence must be so conclusive as to exclude every rational doubt of prisoner's guilt ; for if, after hearing all the evidence , the mind of the jury is in such condition that it cannot say it feels a moral certainty of the truth of the charge, then there arises a doubt , which must operate in favor of the accused . In the case under consideration we find that the cause of death was not made out by the prosecution , at the trial , with that degree of certainty that the law requires , and this , we would observe , was material to lay a founda- tion of guilt . There is no evidence to prove that from the pressure made upon the deceased , by one of the prisoners , she , within a reasonable time thereafter , became sick and , languishing , died . There is no evi- dence to prove that prisoners actually inflicted the injuries upon the deceased , that constitute the body of the crime , as laid in the indictment . On the contrary , it was given in evidence that the deceased was in unusual