LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 489 the court rejected , upon the ground that defendant was barred from introducing any new evidence which had not been previously introduced in the case . This the Supreme Court says was error . (II Bouv . Law Dict. under the head of "New Trial ." ) The arguments by the respective attorneys being concluded , the court sub- mitted the case to the jury for verdict , when a second verdict was found for defendant ; whereupon the plain- tiff excepted and prayed an appeal to the Supreme Court. Now, then , this court says that it is most difficult to understand how the two juries could find two verdicts for the defendant, seeing that all of the rulings of the court on the written pleadings of the case , and on the evidence , were in favor of the plaintiff. The defendant , as the record shows , was allowed to put in only one receipt as evidence , and that having no money value . A careful review of the whole case , in all its parts , as it was before the court below , has certainly perplexed this court no little . Throwing upon it all the light possible , the irregularities are of such a nature that this court would not be able to give equitable justice in the premises , but would have been compelled to remand the case for a new trial , had not the counsel for both parties mutually agreed to submit all of the evidence of every nature-contracts , receipts and book accounts— that had been previously offered in the court below as evidence , and rejected , that we might be satisfied as to the nature and justness of the claim . The counsel on both sides made the following motion : Whereas , it appears from the record in the above entitled cause (J. W. West , appellant, vs. J. G. Montgomery , appellee ) the copy of the agree- ment , receipts and book-account were offered in the lower court as evidence and were not transmitted to the honorable Supreme Court with the record in the said case , and wishing substantial justice done to all , the attorneys at law for and on behalf of the appellant and appellee joined in tendering the above referred to agreement , receipts and book -account to your honors, for your review , in connection with other records in said case . Respectfully submitted , F. E. R. JOHNSON and S. A. Ross , Counsellors for Appellant . CHAS . B. DUNBAR, Counsellor at Law, for Appellee .