282 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS years , which this court in this present decision does not feel authorized to overthrow or to disturb . However , as the decision referred to does not annunciate the doc- trine that a lease would be illegal if it contained a term of years , subject to a renewal of said term after the expiration of the first , this court is of the opinion that the lease in question for twenty years , to be renewed after the expiration of the first term , is not against the Constitution of Liberia nor the decision of this court referred to , and such leases may be made by the owners of lands to suit their own convenience ; otherwise owners would not have absolute right to property in their own. hands , but would be merely trustees of the same. We shall now briefly consider the facts in this case . In the record it appears that one Mrs. E. M. Morris , the owner of lots numbered 59 and 110 , in the city of Greenville , Sinoe County , by deed , leased said lots to one Jose B. Oliver , his heirs , administrators , executors or assigns , for a term of twenty years , for five hundred dollars , being the lease money. Said lease was to be renewed at the will or desire of the said Oliver after the expiration of twenty years , he paying all the taxes and giving one dollar, and further delivering up all improve- ments at the end of the second term , to the lessor . That this covenant not only bound the parties to the trans- action, but all claiming under them, is the opinion of this court . It appears that soon after the transaction referred to , the said Mrs. E. M. Morris sold to plaintiff below her fee titles to the said lots numbered 59 and 110 , but in her deed to the plaintiff points out the lease of the said Oliver , so as to convey to her a future estate . This in the first instance constitutes a bar to an entry, and also admits the right of entry of the said Oliver , upon the terms and recitals in both his and her deed . And it further appears , that shortly afterwards both Mrs. Morris and Oliver died , and this event