230 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS Third . We are of opinion that in actions of this nature , where litigants disagree as to counter claims or set -offs , the matter ought to be referred to arbitration , agree- able to the 12th section of the 15th chapter of the First Book of Liberia Statutes ; and as the admissibility of the evidence belongs to the court and the credibility to the jury, the court below should have either rejected defendants ' account entirely or admitted it altogether . (See Liberia Statute , Book 1 , Chap . 10, sec . 18. ) An account presented in a court of justice as a set -off is evidence of a claim against the alleged debt , but is not conclusive until a verdict and judgment have been ren- dered thereon ; therefore the account of the defendants in this case below should have been taken altogether and submitted to the jury , and not in part . Fourth . As to the fourth , fifth and sixth exceptions , we are of opinion that the account filed by the plain- tiffs is not such an one as the statute requires ; but as it is the only one defendants gave plaintiffs , we must regard it as being the best evidence the case admits . In respect to the witness McGill we are of opinion that the court below did not err in not admitting him, for a Custom House receipt or a copy from the Custom House books under seal would have been better evidence . Fifth . Appellant in his eighth exception below says he motioned the court for a new trial on the following grounds : 1 , Because the verdict of the jury is contrary to law in this , that after the petit jury had retired for deliberation they admitted to their room one D. E. Howard , who assisted them to make their calculations , which resulted against the defendant below . 2 , Because the lower court was informed of the fact of the conduct of the jury , and the court for its better information placed D. E. Howard on oath , who testified in open court that he went into the jury's room ; whether he was called or went himself he could not say, but that on coming to court in the morning the jury handed in their