+500 LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS WILLIAM GRAY , Appellant, vs. GIBASELY BEV- ERLY , Appellee . [ January Term , A. D. 1907. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Habeas Corpus . Where a writ of habeas corpus is directed to a sheriff , commanding him to produce certain aborigines in court , and he makes a return to the writ that he had previously taken them into custody and delivered them to a native chief , by order of the Secretary of Interior so to do , such return is not sufficient to warrant the court , to which the writ is returnable , to discharge the sheriff from the responsibility of producing the prisoners before it . This suit was brought into the Court of Quarter Ses- sions and Common Pleas for Montserrado County , upon a writ of habeas corpus issued by order of the judge of said court , under date June 6th , A. D. 1905 , which was directed or addressed to the appellee , defendant in the court below , commanding him , the said appellee , to produce in court the persons of Vombah Fahine and Carwee , who , it was alleged in the petition praying for the writ , were the wife and child of appellant and that they were in the unlawful custody of the appellee . The service of the writ upon the appellee was certified by the sheriff under date of June 12th of the same year , but from the record it appears that notwithstanding the due and legal service of said writ upon the appellee as aforesaid , the prisoners , Vombah Fahine and Carwee , named therein were not produced in court as the writ directed , nor did the appellee make any return what- ever to said writ . This necessitated the issuing of a compulsory writ of habeas corpus , which was duly sued out under date the 20th of March , A. D. 1906 , and ser- vice upon appellee was certified by the sheriff on the 2d of April of the same year . To this second or compulsory writ the defendant , now appellee , made a return alleging inter alia that he had