LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 487 court below ; but a review of the record will show that irregularities still exist in the conduct of the case in the court below , as well as in the several rulings , to wit : 1. Plaintiff , now appellant , brought an action of debt on a written instrument in the court below , to recover three thousand two hundred and thirty -nine dollars and twenty-three cents, as is laid in the declaration . The defendant , now appellee , joined issue by filing an answer of general denial of the truth contained in the declara- tion , which he said he was ready to prove . In the meantime defendant , now appellee , served on plaintiff, now appellant , a notice to the effect that he desired to put in evidence , at the trial of the case , the contract or agreement made and entered into between them in the month of October , A. D. 1902 , and also notified the plaintiff, now appellant , to produce the original contract before the court at its March term , A. D. 1905. Sub- sequently , the court below gave a ruling against the appellee's answer , to the effect that it formed no part of the record in the case , upon the grounds that it was not intelligible and distinct , nor was it a sufficient answer to plaintiff's complaint . In the opinion of this court , the court below erred in its ruling on this point , which ruling is against the statute regulating the form of an answer , which gives defendant the right to answer by general denial any declaration made against him . (Lib . Stat. Chap . 5 , secs . 1 , 2 , 3 and 4. ) 2. Upon the dismissal of the defendant's (now appel- lee's ) answer , the court proceeded to render an imperfect judgment , upon the ground that the answer was not intelligible or distinct , or a sufficient answer to the com- plaint , and subsequently submitted the finding of the debt claimed to the jury, in which this court says the court below erred . In the case of an imperfect judg- ment for the plaintiff in an action of debt , in which there is a written instrument , or instruments , ascertaining the amount of the debt , it shall be the duty of the court to