LIBERIAN LAW REPORTS 65 However , the defendant, Edward Liles , having filed in court his answer to the plaintiff, Charles Batam's , complaint , the defendant is therefore bound by the same to the extent of the legal right of the plaintiff to recover against him. Upon the examination of the returns of Judge D. F. Smith , it seems that his objection offered for not pro- ceeding with the case was based upon several grounds , one of which this court regards as being well founded : that is , the judge had denied the defendant the privilege of a change of venue , believing it was his duty to do so ; therefore he held that he could not , in justice to all parties , force him , the defendant, to trial after having thus denied him this privilege . It was certainly the privilege of the defendant equally as legal as that of the plaintiff to renew his action after a non-suit, and it ought not to have been denied him . However, the court says and commands that the said Judge D. F. Smith of the aforesaid court of Grand Bassa County proceed to exercise jurisdiction over said case , securing to both parties, however , all the privileges given them by law. The clerk of this court is hereby com- manded to forward a copy of this mandate to Judge D. F. Smith of the Court of Quarter Sessions of Grand Bassa County .