1 LLR 96
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 96. Source pages 96–98 (PDF pages 106–108). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1878. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
96 JULIA ANN WILLIAMS , Appellant, vs. MCGILL & BROTHERS , Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1878. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Action of Debt . This case is before the court on a bill of exceptions . It is a case in which the appeal was granted before final judgment had been given . The law declares that "every person against whom any judgment is rendered shall be entitled to appeal from any decision or opinion of any court , except courts of appeal ." No judgment having been given in this case for this court to confirm or reverse , the court therefore adjudges that the case is hereby dismissed , and that the appellees recover from the appellant their costs in this appeal . The clerk is hereby commanded to issue a mandate to the court below from whence this case came , informing it of the action of this court . THOMAS H. CASSELL , Appellant , vs. MATILDA RICHARDSON , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1878. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Action of Injunction . This is a case of injunction brought on appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County . Upon a motion by appellant that "in this case the appellee having been duly served with notice of appeal , and she having died , and no one appearing to defend the appellee , the appellant respectfully motions the Supreme Court for judgment by default , " a judgment by default was 97 entered against the said appellee . It now remains to pronounce perfect judgment . The court adjudges that the decree of the court below in this case is reversed , and the injunction dissolved , and the clerk of the court is hereby commanded to issue notice to the court below accordingly . REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA, Appellant , vs. THE ES- TATE OF W. S. ANDERSON , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1878. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . An action of debt is the proper form of action to be chosen when the action is one growing out of contract expressed or implied, other than for non -performance, damages or injunction . Upon the examination of this case , an action of debt , brought up on appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions. and Common Pleas , Montserrado County , we find that on motion of defendant , now appellee , of the following tenor ,-"that the case be dismissed and the plaintiff ruled to costs , because the action of debt is not the proper action to be brought in this case, as the defendant , W. S. Anderson , was an officer of the government, and as such was under contract with the government ," the court below decided that "plaintiff in this action should have brought an action of contract against the defen- dant , according to law ; that not being done , the motion is sustained and the case dismissed with costs ." That this cause of action is one growing out of con- tract is very clear indeed ; as much was implied in the defendant's motion to dismiss the case . It has become our duty to find to which of the several subdivisions of "actions growing out of contracts ," as set forth in our statutes, the present case should properly be referred . Confining ourselves to the record , as is our duty, nothing was apparent to show that the plaintiff, having sustained 98 an injury by reason of a non-performance of some con- tract, sought for damages ; or that it was a proper case for the application of an injunction , or that a specific performance , other than for the payment of money, was sought to be enforced. The action of debt lies for a sum of money certain due by the defendant to the plaintiff, whether it has been certain by contract between the parties, or by judgment , or by statute . ( 2 Bouv . Inst . sec . 3455. ) It lies upon contract without specialty , either expressed or implied . It is a more extensive remedy for the recovery of money than assumpsit or covenant , for it lies to recover money due on legal liabilities , as for money lent , paid , had and received , or due on an account stated , or upon simple contracts , expressed or implied , whether oral or written , whenever the demand is for a sum certain or it is capable of being reduced to a certainty . (2 Bouv . Inst. sec. 3459.) Our statutes define it to be "an action to enforce the payment of a sum of money which the defendant has contracted to pay to the plaintiff." The action , as appears from the records , is for a sum certain, which the plaintiff, now appellant , claims that the defendant, now appellee , had contracted to pay, and having failed to do so, an enforcement of the payment was sought , and in the view of this court is properly brought as an action of debt . The court therefore adjudges that the judgment of the lower court is reversed , and the case is remanded to said court for trial , costs to follow .
Selected judicial document
Williams v. McGill et al
Supreme Court of Liberia