1 LLR 93
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 93. Source pages 93–95 (PDF pages 103–105). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1878.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
93 J. N. LEWIS , Plaintiff in Error , vs. REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA , Defendant in Error. [January Term , A. D. 1878.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . This case was brought up by writ of error from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Mont- serrado County . The case having been called up , the Attorney General , for the defendant in error , offered a motion that this court " strike the said case from its docket because since entering said case , by John N. Lewis , Secretary of the State , plaintiff in error , he has died , by which death the action abates " ; and in this motion the counsel for the plaintiff in error concurred . This being one of the cases in which the right of an action dies with the person , therefore this court adjudges that by reason of the death of J. N. Lewis , plaintiff in error in this suit, the action abates as if no such action or suit ever existed ; and orders that the clerk will strike said case from the docket of this court . H. COOPER, Appellant , vs. McGILL & BROS . , Appellees . [January Term , A. D. 1878. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Interlocutory judgment-Appeal-Final judgment . An appeal cannot be taken from an interlocutory judgment . The appellate court will not review cases by piecemeal . Appeals , where provided for by statutes , must be taken in strict accordance with the provisions of the statutes relating to same . Final judgment is that which puts an end to the matter in contro- versy , so far as the same is within the purview of the court. Until final judgment no valid appeal can be taken . This is an action of injunction brought up on appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . From the record in this case it 94 appears that no final decree was given in the court below , but that the appeal was taken after an inter- locutory decree that did not put an end to the issues in the case . In the case of Minus vs. Crayton before this court at its session of 1874 , the following decision was given : "That no appeal lies from a court of inferior jurisdiction to the Supreme Court, until after final judgment has been given " ; a principle with respect to appellate proceedings fully sustained by law , and not without reason . "The appellate court," says Freeman on Judgments (sec . 33 ) , "will not review cases by piecemeal . The interests of litigants require that causes should not be prematurely brought to the higher courts. The errors complained of might be corrected in the court in which they originated , or the party injured by them , notwith- standing the injury , have final judgment in his favor . If a judgment interlocutory in its nature were the sub- ject of appeal , each of such judgments rendered in the case could be brought before the appellate court , and litigants harrassed by useless delay and expense and the courts burdened with unnecessary labor ." On motion offered during the present session of this court , we stated that an appeal is a privilege or relief authorized by statute , and must be regulated by the provisions of the act so granting it ; and we still enter- tain the same view as to its nature in this respect . Our statute provides that "every person against whom any judgment is rendered shall be entitled to an appeal from any decision or opinion of any court , except such courts of appeals ." (Lib . Stat . 1st Book , p . 77, ch. 20, sec . 1. ) But the sixth section of the same chapter declares , "Every appeal must be taken within sixty days after final judg- ment ." Thus, while the right to appeal from every decision, interlocutory or final , is granted , the appeal cannot be taken until after final judgment is rendered . Again our statute provides "that in all cases which 95 shall be decided by the Court of Common Pleas , the per- son or persons considering himself or themselves ag- grieved by such decision , may appeal to the Supreme Court after such decision , i.e. , after the decision deciding the case ." (Lib . Stat . 1st Book , p . 109 , sec. 9. ) But it is needless to enlarge upon this point so fully established even by the learned counsels themselves (representing either side in this case ) who during the present session ably submitted arguments and citations to authorities in this and other cases , to sustain this position , that a party should not appeal and remove his case from the court below before final judgment . A final judgment or decree is one that puts an end to the suit , or , in other words , completely disposes of the cause, so far as the court had power to dispose of it. It is a judicial decision of this character , settling the right or interest in controversy between parties to a cause , that is essential to invoke appellate jurisdiction . An adjudication , however , is not final so long as a question which it was one of the objects of the suit to determine , remains undetermined , and the rights of the party thereto remain preserved for further adjudica- tion . Such appears to be the nature of this case ; the rights of the parties have not yet been decided upon ; no final judgment has been rendered in the case , and therefore the bringing it up to this court is premature . We have observed the several exceptions taken to the matters ruled upon during the trial of this case in the lower court , but not regarding the case as being properly before us for review we do not propose to examine these exceptions . It is decreed that the case be dismissed , and appel- lant ruled to pay costs . The clerk is hereby com- manded to issue a mandate to the court from whence this case came , informing it of this decree .
Selected judicial document
Lewis v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia