1 LLR 86
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 86. Source pages 86–90 (PDF pages 96–100). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1876.].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
86 ALEXANDER LEE , Plaintiff in Error , vs. REPUB- LIC OF LIBERIA, Defendant in Error. [January Term , A. D. 1876.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Bastardy . The writ of error brings to this court a question be- tween the judgment in the case in the court below and the law. This court shall therefore proceed to consider the question involved in the same . The error complained of is that the court below erred in giving final judgment in the case upon a default of the defendant below . From the record in the case , this court discovers great irregu- larities in the proceedings had in the court below upon the case . The court below upon a default of the defendant below ordered that the plaintiff in error (defendant below ) enter into recognizance with good securities for the maintenance of the child , and to pay into the Sub -Treasury of Sinoe County the sum of one dollar per week, payable monthly . And as soon as the said Alexander Lee can be had , the sheriff or his deputy shall cause him to appear before this court , or the judge thereof , to enter into the aforesaid recognizance . Inthe making of this order the court below erred ; because , if the plaintiff in error (defendant below ) had failed to appear at the time of trial , the proper action of the court below would have been to give judgment against the bond of the defendant below , which bond the statute directs should be taken from the defendant as a security for his appearance to the Court of Quarter Sessions , that the said court may make such order in the case as may be proper and lawful to do . It is the bond that gives the Court of Quarter Sessions jurisdiction over such cases , and enables it to proceed thereupon . Therefore , this court adjudges that the order made by the Court of Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , in the 87 said case of Alexander Lee , plaintiff in error , against the Republic of Liberia , defendant in error , be and is hereby set aside and made void and of no legal effect what- ever ; and that the said Republic of Liberia , defendant in error, pay all costs incurred in this action. WALTER BROWN , Agent for A. Warmann , Plaintiff in Error, vs. F. J. GRANT , Defendant in Error . [January Term , A. D. 1876.] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . 1. A jury may deliver its verdict viva voce in open court , but it is error in a court to order its clerk to write out the verdict of the jury. If a verdict be illegal , the judgment founded thereupon will be illegal also. After a verdict has been entered upon the record, an authentic copy thereof will be admissible as evidence of its existence . 2. It is error in a court to refuse to reduce to writing its ruling on any point made in a trial . 3. A party may waive his right to move for a new trial without losing his right to move in arrest of judgment . This court , having examined the errors assigned , will now proceed to give its opinion on the several points submitted , as they come up in order . The first error assigned is thus stated : " Because there is no legal ver- dict of the jury in the case according to law and the custom of the court ." Upon this point this court says the court below is correct in ruling that the jury could come into court and give its verdict viva voce , and this ruling was the evidence to the jury of the law of the land ; but the court below erred in ordering , contrary to its own ruling , the clerk to write out the verdict of the jury , and to cause the foreman to cross - mark the same , the clerk attaching his name thereto as a witness , notwithstanding the clerk was not a member of that body . The second error assigned is thus set forth : " Because judgment ought not to have been rendered without a 88 legal verdict ." In respect to this point this court says the verdict having been returned contrary to the ruling of the court below , judgment ought not to have been rendered thereupon ; because the judgment of the court is the sentence of the law and therefore it could not be justly founded upon an illegal an illegal verdict . verdict . Hence it is an error in the court below rendering the said judgment . The third error assigned is stated thus : "Because the clerk of the court could not be made a witness to the jury's verdict ." Upon this point this court says the verdict must be the evidence of its own existence until it is entered on the records of the court ; after which a copy may be used in proof of the existence of such a verdict , the copy having thereto attached the seal of the court and the official signature of the clerk . In no other way can a clerk be made a witness to the jury's verdict ; but to ascertain whether the jury have unanimously agreed upon their verdict , the opinion of each juryman may be demanded by any party to the action . Thus it is obvious that the law contemplates no other evidence , in confirmation or contradiction of the verdict of a jury , but that expressed by the jury themselves . Therefore this court says the court below having allowed the clerk to sign the verdict of the jury , as a witness thereto , erred in so doing . The fourth error assigned is set forth thus : "Because Your Honor refused to hear a motion in arrest of judg- ment presented by the defendant's attorney , and also refused to reduce your opinion to writing , according to law." To this point this court says the court below ought to have given the motion of the plaintiff in error (defendant below ) a hearing , whether the motion was entertained or not ; and this should have been done , upon the principle that we should hear before we condemn . And further the court below ought to have ordered the motion to be entered upon the records of the court 89 together with the opinion or reason of the court for not entertaining the same. The refusal of the court to reduce its opinion to writing is a denial of a legal right , and an obstruction against the regular mode of obtaining an appeal . And for these reasons this court says the court below erred in refusing to hear the motion in arrest of judgment , and also in refusing to reduce its opinion to writing . A party waiving his right to a new trial does not bar him- self of a right to an arrest of judgment ; because it is a well - settled principle that a waiver of one legal right does not debar one from resorting to another . Therefore , this court adjudges that the judgment rendered in the case above mentioned , in the Court of Quarter Sessions , Sinoe County , against the said Walter Brown , agent for A. Warmann , of Hamburg , plaintiff in error , in said action of damages for the viola- tion of a written contract is hereby reversed , set aside and made void and of no legal effect whatever ; and that the said plaintiff in error recover from the said F. · J. Grant , defendant in error , his costs in this action . THOMAS CASSELL , Appellant , vs. MATILDA RICHARDSON , Appellee . [ January Term , A. D. 1876. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Statute of Limitation - Written evidence - New trial . A plea specially pleading the Statute of Limitation in bar to a suit is a question purely of law , and by statute must be determined by the court , independent of a jury . Where a written instrument is offered in evidence , it should form a part of the record , even though it be not admitted as evidence , in order that the appellate court , upon an appeal , may ascertain whether it is proper evidence or not . This case is sent up from the Court of Quarter Sessions , Montserrado County , upon a bill of exceptions . 90 The case presents many questions , some of which are very important and proper for this court to determine . The desire of this court being to do justice between the parties, it will notice only those questions important to the decision of this case , a solution of which can but force the court to the conclusion it has come to. It is the opinion of this court that a plea specially pleading the Statute of Limitation in bar to a suit is a question purely of law , and under the statutes of this Republic could only be tried and determined by the court . Hence the court below erred in deciding that this plea is a mixed question of law and fact , as well as in submitting the same on the trial for the determination of the jury. The court is further of the opinion that any written instrument or paper whatever that may be offered in evidence , notwithstanding the court does not receive it as evidence in the case , yet said paper , being part of the proceedings , ought to be sent up for review upon an appeal , with the ruling of the court thereon . Hence it was an error in the court below refusing to allow such paper to be annexed to the record as part of the proceedings . It is further the opinion of this court that the right of the judge of the lower court to grant a new trial in any question of mere fact or mixed question of law and fact, tried at any regular term of court , grows out of the statutes regulating trials , notwithstanding the party aggrieved by such ruling or order has a right to appeal therefrom . This court is also of opinion , after carefully examining the record of this case , that substantial justice has been done by the jury's verdict . Therefore the court adjudges from the issue joined by the parties below and the proof thereon , that the appellee , Matilda Richardson , by the Statute of Limitation is barred from all and any legal claims to lot No. 200 in the city of Monrovia , and that appellee pay all costs of trial .
Selected judicial document
Lee v. Republic
Supreme Court of Liberia