1 LLR 8
Source-verified historic case report · Volume I
The printed reporter identifies this case at 1 LLR 8. Source pages 8–12 (PDF pages 18–22). Term: [January Term , A. D. 1861. ].
This transcription comes from the preserved PDF text layer. Its source caption and page boundaries were checked against the printed reporter, but the transcription has not been independently proofread against every scanned page. Refer to the scanned original for quotations.
8 JOHNSON , TURPIN and DUNBAR , Appellants , vs. J. J. ROBERTS , Appellee . [January Term , A. D. 1861. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Montserrado County . Record-Evidence- Bond . 1. Party appealing should superintend the appeal and see that all legal requisites are completed . 2. It is indispensable that the records in an appeal contain the evi- dence submitted in the lower court . 3. The court will not entertain a case legally deficient in its rec- ords. The omission of a copy of the bond in the records is diminution of records and is fatal to an appeal . This court , having reviewed the records sent from said court , as well as the questions propounded by the attorneys for the respective parties, feels itself bound to answer the same , as well as to cause its acts to be in strict accordance with the law governing appeals sent to this court . First-There are material defects in the records for- warded to this court , the most prominent of which is that the evidence in the case is wholly omitted , notwith- standing it is indispensable to the decision of every case pending before a court of judicature . The court cannot entertain any case that is legally deficient in its records . A true copy of the bond is indis- pensably necessary to be forwarded , the original to be retained on the files below , as the security of the court on behalf of him against whom the appeal is taken . All cases sent forward on appeal must be taken out within sixty days , having the signature of the judge to the exceptions , as well as all other preliminaries contem- plated by the law relating to appeals . These pre- liminaries are indispensably necessary to a legal appeal . The clerk whose duty it is to forward the records of the court under seal cannot do so unless the parties suing file bond , according to law, and the party appeal- 9 ing ought here themselves superintend the lawful pre- requisites . It is for the safety of the parties that said requisitions be met, and it must therefore be a gross injustice to the appellee to compel him to answer to any appeal taken out contrary to law. The law will not admit of invasions upon itself , and for the court to entertain any appeal which may be deficient in its most important and indispensable features , and which are most calculated to lead to a just decision in the case , would not be in keeping with the record and inviolable rights of the nation . Therefore the court decides that said case be dis- missed , with all costs in this court . SAVINIA E. BROWN, Appellant , vs. FRANCIS PAYNE , Appellee . [January Term , A.D. 1861. ] Appeal from the Court of Quarter Sessions and Common Pleas , Sinoe County . Ejectment- Husband and wife-Courtesy . 1. The husband cannot inherit the property of his wife at her death ; nor does he acquire a title therein by virtue of coverture ; nor can he dispose of it without her express authority under the Constitution of Liberia. 2. Where during coverture an heir capable of inheriting has been born , the husband , on the death of the wife , may hold her estate as a tenant by the courtesy, but he cannot sell or otherwise dispose of said estate by virtue of the coverture . The general view to be taken of the law governing titles and claims , and also possession , should be in all its parts alike , especially whenever the right of property is questioned . The case reviewed before this court on a plea of eject- ment brought up on appeal from the decision and judg- ment of the court below is interesting as may it appear to be complex , as it does most assuredly invalue the rights of parties purchasing from those supposed to have 10 had the right to sell . Its antiquity and the circum- stances connected thereto would at first view , aside from reflection and the law governing the case , cause appre- hension that the innocent would be compelled to suffer pursuant to the acts of the wrongdoers . Ejectment is an ancient remedy coming down to us , greatly modified and arranged suitably to the circum- stances of the present age . It lies to recover the posses- sion of lands, with damages and cost , for the wrongful withholding of them , being the principal method now in use for trying titles to lands . The particularities of this action are fully explained in the words of Blackstone on Real Property . The commencement of this action presupposes the real title to the land from which the parties are to be ejected . The appellant denies the right of the plaintiff to recover the property consequent upon the purchase being made by the appellant from the son of the legal possessor of said property . The appellee equally claims special right to said lands , as being purchased from the husband of the woman who held possession in her own. right after the death of her husband , Seiper , and her heir or son , who after the death of his mother held no claim to the land held in fee simple by his mother . Hence the pivot of the question appears to be resting upon the right of possession by inheritance . Our constitutional law has established a perma- nent basis respecting the property of a woman , as to how it shall be disposed of and by whom ; but as this is a question of some moment requiring deliberate action , involving , as it does , considerable interest , it would be well to treat a little upon the right of the husband in the property of his wife , which she was possessed of at the time of her marriage , as well as also to speak of the law governing descent in such actions , when occurring under the circumstances . There is a way by which the husband can come in pos- 11 session of the property of his wife of which she was in possession at the time of her marriage . But that pos- session is only temporary in some cases by the principle of courtesy , a term used to explain this particular mode of proceeding . It is thus defined : "An estate to which a man is by law entitled on the death of his wife"— the lands of which she was possessed during marriage in fee simple , provided he had issue by her during mar- riage , and capable of inheriting her estate . ( 1st Stept. 246 ) . It is a species of freehold estate , not of inheri- tance , equally known to English , Scotch and American law (4th Kent's Comm . 27-28 ) ,-courtesy as understood in its ordinary sense of favor . The estate being enjoyed rather by favor of law , e gratia legis, than as a matter of right , this special favor accrues from the existence of the fact of his having issue by her , and holding his right and possession for the legal title to be given at the proper time , and the next heir of kin to the wife can claim a right , which would be the same if she had two or more relatives. It is given as authority that the husband acquires a right to the use of all the lands or real estate of the wife during her life , but not to sell , and also during his own life , if he has a child by her as a tenant of the courtesy . ( 1st Swift , Dig . 26. ) Hence it is clear that the husband cannot dispose of real estate of which his wife was in possession at the time of marriage , and all land disposed of under such title is "null and void ." If Byrd obtained his title from Mrs. Seiper , and upon that right possessed by marriage , and affixes his seal as valid , it is clear , then , without a shadow of doubt , that Mrs. Seiper's right must be unquestionable , and if we supposed Mr. Payne to have had a perfect right devised from Mr. Byrd , this , also , is another reason which influences the court to preponderate in favor of the right , the bona fide right of Mrs. Seiper before marriage . As far as regulations of the Colonization Society are con- 12 cerned , the whole arrangement appears to be clear and consistent to the court , and that a woman may draw lands on her arrival here for herself and children , and this being true it follows that at her death her children heir the property . With respect to the doubts expressed in reference to Parsons being the son of Mrs. Seiper , alias Mrs. Byrd , the law will presume him to be her lawful heir until the contrary is shown . This point should have been con- tested and established in the court below . The evi- dence in the case is not material , especially that in parole , as it is held that a proposition made by a party to effect a settlement is not admissable in evidence against him. ( Mitchell vs. Preston , 5 Day, 100. ) This is both reasonable and just in every respect . In proving confession , the whole must be taken together . ( 1 Root , 434.) Parsons was the rightful inheritor after the death of his mother , Mrs. Seiper , to a clear and definite title by descent . ( Refer to Dutton Comm . Digest , page 77. ) Therefore , with the foregoing conclusions it is the opinion and judgment of this court that the title of Joseph S. Brown and James E. Brown is valid , and that Parsons , as the only remaining heir of Mrs. Seiper , was the sole owner at her death , and have the right to sell said lands . It is decreed by the court that the judg- ment of the Court of Sinoe County in this case of eject- ment be reversed , and that said property remain in the possession of James and Joseph S. Brown's estate undis- turbed , with costs of court , and that a mandate be issued directing and commanding the same .
Selected judicial document
Johnson et als. v. Roberts
Supreme Court of Liberia